The original contest looked simple: online shops offered greater choice and convenience, while physical stores appeared slow and expensive. By 2026, that distinction has become less useful. Online shopping continues to grow, but the strongest businesses combine digital discovery, efficient fulfilment and physical service.
The numbers support this more balanced view. Eurostat reports that 78% of EU internet users bought goods or services online in 2025, up from 62% in 2015. In the United States, e-commerce grew faster than total retail sales in the second quarter of 2026, yet still represented 17.1% of total retail sales. E-tailers are gaining share, but most retail spending has not moved entirely online.
So, are e-tailers winning? They are winning important parts of the customer journey. They do not automatically win the customer relationship, the economics of fulfilment or the final sale.
Where e-tailers have the advantage
Online retail is exceptionally strong at search, comparison and convenience. A customer can compare products and prices, read reviews, check availability and place an order without travelling to a store. Digital retailers can offer a wider assortment than most physical locations and reach customers far beyond their home market.
They also generate behavioural data. Search terms, abandoned baskets and repeat purchases can improve forecasting and personalisation. AI now supports product discovery, customer service, fraud detection and demand planning.
More automation does not guarantee better decisions. Poor recommendations, inaccurate descriptions and automated support loops can destroy trust. Retailers still need reliable data and an easy path to a person when the customer has a complex problem.
Where physical retailers remain stronger
Stores provide immediacy and certainty. Customers can see dimensions and colours, test a device, try on clothing, ask questions and leave with the product. This matters most where fit, feel, advice, installation or trust influence the decision. Physical locations can also support repairs, returns, demonstrations and local relationships.
A store can act as a showroom, service centre, local warehouse, collection point and returns hub. A shop that fulfils nearby orders or enables collection can reduce failed deliveries and generate additional purchases.
The disadvantage is the fixed-cost base. Rent, staffing and duplicated inventory are expensive. A retailer operating its website and stores separately can end up with the costs of both and the advantages of neither.
The category often decides the balance
Standardised products with clear specifications are naturally suited to online purchasing. Customers need less advice and can compare price, availability and delivery easily. Services such as accounting, legal advice and healthcare have also adopted digital consultations and document workflows, although their delivery remains subject to professional, privacy and sector-specific rules.
Physical retail remains especially valuable where customers need fitting, sensory assessment, reassurance or immediate problem-solving. Furniture, premium goods, complex electronics and services linked to installation often benefit from human assistance. Even within one category, the appropriate balance can differ: routine repeat purchases may move online, while the first purchase or a higher-value decision begins in a store. Retail strategy should therefore follow the decision risk and service need, not a general assumption about the superiority of one channel.
Pure online retail has difficult economics
The online storefront is scalable, but fulfilment is not free. Every order may involve acquisition costs, payment fees, picking, packaging, delivery, support and returns. Nominally free shipping hides a cost that must be absorbed elsewhere.
Returns matter in categories where customers cannot assess fit or appearance before ordering. They tie up capital, increase handling and can leave goods unsuitable for full-price resale. What matters is the contribution remaining after fulfilment and returns.
Marketplace dependence creates another risk. A marketplace offers reach but controls ranking, advertising, customer data and commercial rules. Resilient e-tailers use marketplaces selectively while building their own brand and repeat-purchase channels.
Omnichannel is more than having a website
The likely winners let customers move between channels without friction. That requires more than offering click-and-collect.
A genuine omnichannel model provides:
- one accurate view of inventory across stores and warehouses;
- consistent product information and prices;
- shared customer accounts, loyalty benefits and service history;
- flexible delivery, collection and return options;
- store staff who can access online orders and customer context; and
- financial reporting that shows the full cost and value of each customer relationship.
Performance measurement must follow the same logic. Online research can contribute to a store sale, while a store visit can lead to an online order. Crediting only the final checkout creates poor investment decisions.
EU regulation is reshaping online retail
The compliance gap between selling online and selling in a store has narrowed. Several EU rules now make digital retail more accountable.
The Digital Services Act requires online marketplaces to improve trader traceability and respond to illegal products and content. The General Product Safety Regulation, applicable since December 2024, strengthens product-safety, traceability and recall obligations for goods sold online as well as offline. Online product offers must include required manufacturer, responsible-person and safety information where applicable.
The European Accessibility Act has applied to covered e-commerce services since June 2025. Online journeys, identification, payment and communication must be assessed for accessibility. Specific exemptions and transitional rules may apply.
The Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation began applying on 12 August 2026, with requirements introduced in phases. E-tailers should review packaging specifications, supplier evidence and fulfilment processes now.
From 27 September 2026, Directive (EU) 2024/825 also tightens environmental claims and sustainability labels. Generic terms such as “green” or “sustainable” may be prohibited without the required evidence. Online and in-store claims must be consistent and supportable.
Sustainability depends on the operating model
Neither channel is automatically greener. A consolidated delivery route may replace several individual car journeys, but urgent shipping, split deliveries, failed deliveries, excessive packaging and high return rates can erase the advantage. A store also carries impacts from buildings, energy, inventory and customer travel.
Retailers should measure their actual order profile: packaging, delivery density, transport mode, failed deliveries, returns, resale and store or warehouse energy. Consolidated delivery, better size guidance, repair services and collection points can improve both cost and environmental performance.
What retailers should do now
Start with customer needs. Identify where customers require convenience, advice, physical inspection, speed or reassurance, then choose the profitable mix of digital and physical capabilities.
Priorities include accurate product and inventory data, accessible design, reliable fulfilment, fraud protection and returns that preserve product value. Test AI where it solves a measurable problem, but keep responsibility for pricing, claims and customer outcomes with people.
The objective is not to maximise online revenue in isolation. It is to improve lifetime value, service quality and contribution after acquisition, delivery and returns.
Conclusion: e-tailers win share, hybrids win customers
E-tailers are still gaining ground because digital shopping is now routine and online tools make discovery and comparison easier. But physical retail retains important advantages, and online growth can hide weak unit economics. The binary contest is ending.
The businesses most likely to win are those that behave as one retailer across every channel. They use stores where physical presence adds value, digital tools where they remove friction, and shared data and operations to connect the two. In 2026, the strategic question is no longer whether online will defeat offline. It is whether a retailer can give customers a coherent experience while remaining profitable, compliant and trusted.
Editorial sources
- Eurostat, Digitalisation in Europe – 2026 edition
- U.S. Census Bureau, Quarterly Retail E-Commerce Sales – Second Quarter 2026
- Eurostat, E-commerce statistics
- European Commission, The Digital Services Act
- EUR-Lex, General Product Safety Regulation
- European Commission, European Accessibility Act
- European Commission, New EU rules on packaging enter into application
- European Commission, Sustainable consumption
Related Links:
Your question about this article
Explore the topic with your own question. Use HUBLink for management and ESGLink for sustainability, ESRS and CO₂e.
Your question will be prepared in the selected chat. You can edit and send it there. Available free questions or your existing access apply.
