Skip to content
Home » Knowledge HUB » Corporate Reporting » ESG Performance Questionnaire in 2026: Evidence and Governance

ESG Performance Questionnaire in 2026: Evidence and Governance

Updated 17 November 2026. Originally published in May 2021.

An ESG questionnaire should establish what a company does, what results it achieves and how reliable the evidence is. This assessment retains four value dimensions: Economy, Social/People, Environment and Compliance/Governance. It supports management decisions and improvement planning. Completing it does not by itself produce an independently verified ESG rating, a compliant sustainability statement or proof that every legal requirement has been met.

Key Takeaways

  • Measure outcomes as well as policies and activities; training counts alone do not demonstrate improvement.
  • Define boundaries, calculation methods and evidence before comparing companies or reporting periods.
  • Use the revised ESRS or the 2026 Voluntary Standard where appropriate, with attention to national law and application dates.
  • Keep serious adverse impacts and evidence gaps visible instead of hiding them inside an aggregate score.

How to start the assessment and interpret results

Identify the purpose: internal improvement, supplier screening, financing discussions or statutory reporting. Specify the entity or group, included sites, value-chain coverage, reporting period and selected framework. Consult relevant stakeholders and assess both impacts on people and the environment and sustainability-related financial risks and opportunities. This provides the two perspectives needed for double materiality where ESRS applies.

For each quantitative indicator, collect three years of actual data where available and show the current-year forecast separately. Record the unit, boundary, denominator, source, calculation method, responsible owner, target and review date. Explain acquisitions, closures or methodology changes before interpreting a trend. Label estimates, exclusions and missing data explicitly.

Use a separate process-maturity assessment if helpful: 0 = a confirmed absence of the assessed process; 1 = a documented policy and owner; 2 = implementation with evidence; 3 = tested effectiveness and corrective action. Mark an unanswered question as unknown, rather than automatically scoring it zero. These are suggested management conventions, not an official rating methodology.

Keep actual performance alongside maturity: for example, injuries, emissions or overdue corrective actions against a defined target. A well-documented process can still have poor results. If management uses weights or an aggregate score, disclose the rationale, coverage and sensitivity. Serious human-rights harm or material non-compliance requires explicit escalation and cannot be offset by good results elsewhere.

1. Economy: financial resilience and business value

  • How have revenue, EBITDA, operating cash flow, liquidity and capital expenditure developed? Specify currency, consolidation basis and exceptional items.
  • Which sustainability-related risks could affect costs, revenue, assets, financing or business continuity? Where are they reflected in budgets and scenarios?
  • Which investments support measurable environmental or social outcomes, and what evidence supports the business case? Separate committed expenditure from proposals.
  • Which criteria justify describing a product or service as sustainable? Report the relevant revenue or activity share against those criteria, rather than only counting products.
  • How do taxes, remuneration, investment and local procurement contribute to stakeholders? Present these separately; adding them does not establish a net monetary benefit to society.

Link material findings to corporate planning. A lower emissions intensity, for example, may improve operating economics, but the financial effect depends on energy prices, volumes, carbon exposure and investment costs. Avoid double counting the same saving in several business cases.

2. Social/People: working conditions and outcomes

  • What are employee headcount, full-time equivalents, hiring and turnover, with consistent definitions? Which relevant contractors or other workers are excluded?
  • What do injury rates, serious incidents, absence and occupational-health assessments show? Include psychological workload where relevant and explain the denominator.
  • Are remuneration, working hours and equal opportunities assessed? What evidence supports conclusions about pay gaps, accessibility and fair career progression?
  • Do training, employee engagement and worker representation lead to demonstrable improvements? Track access and outcomes alongside expenditure.
  • How are human-rights risks, worker complaints and remediation handled in the value chain? Do affected people have safe reporting channels, and are actions effective?

A higher number of complaints can reflect greater trust in reporting. Interpret it alongside severity, investigation quality and resolution. Protect employee information: the EDPB explains that employee consent is generally problematic because of the power imbalance. Identify the appropriate legal basis and any additional conditions for sensitive data; use proportionate aggregation and safeguards against identifying individuals.

3. Environment: resources, emissions and material impacts

  • What is total energy use, including fuels and purchased energy, and what is the renewable share? Separate consumption from energy expenditure.
  • What are gross scope 1 and scope 2 emissions and relevant scope 3 categories? Document inventory boundaries, emission factors, estimates and the chosen accounting approach.
  • What do water withdrawal and consumption show by location, especially in water-stressed areas? Report waste generation, hazardous waste and treatment routes with clear definitions.
  • Which pollution, biodiversity, land-use and resource-efficiency impacts are material? What incidents or permit breaches occurred, and what remediation followed?
  • Are targets linked to a baseline, funded actions and accountable owners? Show absolute and intensity trends separately, with reasons for deviations.

Use a recognised inventory methodology such as the GHG Protocol and distinguish actual gross emissions reductions from carbon credits or avoided-emissions claims. A management-system certificate supports a defined assessment scope; it does not establish that the company has no environmental impacts.

4. Compliance/Governance: effective oversight

  • Which board or management body owns sustainability risks, and how are decisions, delegated authorities and follow-up documented?
  • Is the legal register current for each entity, country and activity? Which statutory duties, customer requirements and voluntary commitments apply?
  • Are internal controls, anti-corruption procedures, conflicts-of-interest rules and whistleblowing arrangements implemented and tested? Where are investigations and overdue actions reported?
  • How are supplier risks, cybersecurity, privacy and AI-assisted decisions governed? Are access rights, evidence sources and human review proportionate to the risk?
  • Are lobbying, political donations and incentives transparent? Do remuneration structures support stated objectives without encouraging concealment or manipulation of data?

Record confirmed incidents, their severity, substantiation and remediation. An absence of identified cases is not proof that controls work. Require evidence of review and appropriate independent challenge, while adapting the control structure to the company’s size and complexity.

What changed in reporting and ratings in 2026?

The adopted Omnibus I Directive narrows the principal EU sustainability-reporting scope to undertakings exceeding both 1,000 employees and €450 million net turnover, with group, exemption and third-country rules. Establish applicability and transition arrangements before treating a questionnaire as a reporting obligation. Smaller companies may still receive information requests from customers and lenders.

The revised ESRS under Regulation (EU) 2026/1563 apply to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. They permit early application for financial years beginning in 2026 and contain transitional reliefs. Record which version is used; do not silently compare indicators with changed definitions.

The 2026 Voluntary Sustainability Reporting Standard, based on VSME, provides a proportionate reporting framework for undertakings outside mandatory reporting. Voluntary reporting under it is already available. Its Article 3 value-chain cap applies from financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027 and concerns specified sustainability-reporting information requests to protected undertakings. It does not eliminate information needed under separate laws, such as product or due diligence rules.

National implementation remains important. Austria’s NaBeG entered into force on 19 February 2026 with phased application and transition arrangements. Germany’s published section 289b HGB still sets out the non-financial declaration regime. Check the applicable national and group-reporting position for the financial year rather than assuming that an EU directive automatically creates the same immediate obligation everywhere.

The EU ESG Ratings Regulation has applied since 2 July 2026 and introduces supervision and transparency requirements for providers within scope. A company’s disclosure of its own sustainability impacts, risks and opportunities is not automatically an ESG rating under the Regulation. If a scoring service is offered externally, assess its actual purpose, distribution and applicable exemptions; the label “questionnaire” does not decide its legal status.

From answers to an improvement plan

For each material gap, record the finding, evidence strength, affected stakeholders, responsible owner, budget and due date. Agree measurable outcomes and follow-up with management. Prioritise serious impacts and legal breaches before minor documentation improvements. Reassess against a consistent baseline and explain changed boundaries or methods.

AI tools can help extract and organise evidence, but cannot substitute for missing data or validate their own conclusions. Keep source references, check calculations and resolve contradictory answers with the responsible teams. Do not upload confidential employee or supplier information to unapproved services.

Conclusion

ESG performance becomes useful when reliable evidence leads to better decisions and measurable improvement. Use this questionnaire as a structured starting point, map relevant answers to the applicable framework and retain a clear distinction between self-assessment, sustainability reporting and external assurance or ratings. Contact STRATECTA for support.

Related Links:

Your question about this article

Explore the topic with your own question. Use HUBLink for management and ESGLink for sustainability, ESRS and CO₂e.

Your question will be prepared in the selected chat. You can edit and send it there. Available free questions or your existing access apply.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Georg Tichy

Georg Tichy

Georg Tichy is a management consultant in Europe, focusing on top-management consultancy, projectmanagement, corporate reporting and fundingsupport. Dr. Georg Tichy is also trainer, lecturer at university and advisor on current economic issues. Contact me or Book a MeetingView Author posts